Exploring the Challenges Faced by Physician-Owned Practices Due to Workforce Declines and Impacts on Patient Experience

Physician-owned practices in the United States are currently navigating a complex landscape characterized by staffing shortages and financial stressors. Particularly during the post-pandemic era, these challenges have led to significant implications for healthcare delivery, patient experience, and the overall economic stability of these practices. With data compiled from the Medical Group Management Association (MGMA), it is evident that the struggle within physician-owned practices has intensified compared to their hospital-owned counterparts.

Financial Performance Discrepancies

Recent reports indicate a notable disparity in financial performance between hospital-owned and physician-owned practices. Hospital-owned practices have demonstrated a 1.79% increase in medical revenue from 2021 to 2022, indicating a recovery trend and better adaptability to changing conditions. In contrast, physician-owned practices, particularly in non-surgical specialties, have experienced substantial financial declines. The most striking finding is the 14.88% revenue decrease that non-surgical specialty practices faced during the same period. This financial downturn creates heightened pressure on physician-owned practices, requiring them to rethink their operational strategies.

Staffing Shortages: A Pressing Concern

A central challenge confronting physician-owned practices is the dramatic reduction in support staff. From 2019 to 2022, staffing levels plummeted from an average of 5.08 support staff per full-time equivalent (FTE) physician to just 3.0. The primary care domain has felt the brunt of these reductions, losing more than three FTE support roles on average in recent years. This situation has not only decreased the available personnel for patient support but has also led to a noticeable drop in morale among the remaining staff.

The impacts of these staffing shortages are multifaceted. As Ron Holder, Chief Operating Officer at the MGMA, noted, the lingering effects of the COVID-19 pandemic have compounded these staffing dilemmas. Practices are grappling with lost productivity and increased recruitment demands, further exacerbating their operational challenges. Increased reliance on temporary and contract workers has emerged as a common solution to fill gaps; however, such strategies can lead to heightened expenses and often lack the continuity that more permanent staff can provide.

The Consequences of Reduced Staffing

The declining number of support staff has had a profound impact on patient experience and care quality. With fewer personnel available to manage patient inquiries and coordinate care, the overall experience for patients has deteriorated. Access to timely appointments has become more challenging, leading to longer wait times and diminished patient satisfaction levels. Moreover, the reduction in staff has strained care coordination, which is critical for effective healthcare delivery.

The financial repercussions associated with reduced staffing are evident in the increased days in accounts receivable and higher claim denials. Practices are now experiencing delays in receiving payments, resulting in missed revenue opportunities. The inability to manage coding errors and underpayments effectively has contributed to these mounting challenges, ultimately affecting the financial health of physician-owned practices.

Examining Patient Experience

The patient experience in physician-owned practices has been significantly impacted by the staffing crisis. As staff members are stretched thin, the quality of care and the patient-provider relationship tend to suffer. Healthcare providers frequently find themselves juggling multiple roles, leading to burnout and increased job dissatisfaction. In an environment where the focus should be on patient-centric care, the lack of adequate support can hinder the ability to provide individualized attention and thorough communication.

Patients today expect accessibility and streamlined communication when seeking medical care. When staffing shortages impede the ability to answer phone calls promptly or provide timely follow-up, frustration grows among patients. These negative experiences can result in diminished trust and loyalty, ultimately shaping patients’ perceptions of the healthcare system as a whole.

Revenue Cycle Management Impacts

The revenue cycle process is another critical area negatively affected by workforce declines. The management of accounts receivable and claim denials has become increasingly challenging as practices struggle to maintain adequate staffing levels. Lengthy accounts receivable days have become common, factoring into the overall financial performance of these practices. The increases in claim denials stem from insufficient staff to carry out proper coding and billing tasks effectively, leading to increased delays in revenue collection.

Moreover, as practices attempt to fill staffing gaps with temporary workers, the inconsistency can exacerbate compliance issues in billing. This lack of continuity can lead to errors and further claims denials, compounding the existing financial strain on physician-owned practices. As many medical groups wrestle with revenue losses, the stress surrounding the revenue cycle can ultimately detract from critical patient care initiatives.

The Role of Technology in Addressing Challenges

Transforming Operations through AI and Workflow Automations

The challenges posed by staffing shortages necessitate innovative solutions that leverage technology. The emergence of artificial intelligence (AI) and workflow automation tools offers promising opportunities for physician-owned practices to enhance efficiency and improve the patient experience.

AI-driven solutions can help manage front-office tasks traditionally handled by personnel, such as answering calls and scheduling appointments. By automating these repetitive functions, practices can free up staff to focus on direct patient care, thereby alleviating some of the burdens facing existing team members. Not only does this help address immediate staffing shortages, but it also allows practices to provide timely and efficient service to patients.

Furthermore, AI can contribute significantly to revenue cycle management. Automated systems can improve coding accuracy and reduce errors in billing, directly impacting the rate of claim denials. By streamlining the revenue cycle process, practices can experience shorter accounts receivable days and quicker revenue realization.

The integration of technology also introduces valuable data analytics capabilities, enabling practices to gain insights into operational performance. With accurate data at their disposal, practice administrators can identify trends, measure performance metrics, and assess the effectiveness of staffing strategies. By harnessing the power of technology, physician-owned practices can navigate current challenges with more agility and responsiveness.

The Path Toward Recovery

As physician-owned practices contend with the dual challenges of workforce declines and deteriorating patient experiences, recovery requires a multi-faceted approach. There is a pressing need for innovative strategies that address both staffing shortages and enhance patient care immediately.

To maximize operational efficacy, practices must consider comprehensive recruitment strategies that focus on attracting and retaining support staff. Offering competitive salaries and improved workplace conditions can assist in addressing staffing shortages. Additionally, fostering a supportive culture that prioritizes staff well-being can enhance morale and encourage greater workforce stability.

In tandem with recruitment efforts, practices should invest in training programs to enhance the skills of existing staff. By equipping personnel with advanced competencies, practices can optimize their performance, thus improving service delivery despite current staffing limitations.

Moreover, a commitment to embracing technology solutions, such as automated services and data analytics, can pave the way for long-term improvements. By integrating AI tools, physician-owned practices can streamline operations, improve efficiency, and enhance patient interactions.

Navigating the challenges posed by workforce declines and their impact on patient experience will require visionary leadership and strategic agility within physician-owned practices. The path forward may be fraught with obstacles, but with innovative solutions and a commitment to excellence in healthcare delivery, these practices can emerge stronger in the post-pandemic era.

With a focus on improving operational efficiency, enhancing patient experiences, and adapting to the demands of a shifting healthcare environment, physician-owned practices can work toward a sustainable future, ensuring they remain valuable healthcare providers in their communities.



References: