The Impact of Medicaid Expansion on Access to Healthcare: A Comparative Analysis of Expansion and Non-Expansion States

In the United States, access to healthcare is a significant issue, with many people struggling to obtain necessary medical services. One factor influencing this access is Medicaid expansion under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). This article offers a comparative analysis of how Medicaid expansion affects healthcare access in expansion and non-expansion states, focusing on low-income populations.

Overview of Medicaid Expansion

The ACA, enacted in 2010, aimed to extend health insurance coverage to more low-income individuals. Medicaid expansion allows states to provide coverage to nearly all adults with incomes up to 138% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL), which is about $20,783 for an individual in 2024. As of May 2024, 41 states, including Washington D.C., have adopted Medicaid expansion, while 10 states have not. This difference greatly affects healthcare access and quality.

The Coverage Gap

In non-expansion states, many low-income individuals find themselves in a coverage gap. They earn too much to qualify for traditional Medicaid but too little to afford private insurance, making them ineligible for subsidized coverage through ACA marketplaces. This has left millions without sufficient access to healthcare services. Recent estimates suggest around 2.2 million Americans, mainly individuals of color and those in the southern United States, are in this situation.

Impacts of Medicaid Expansion

Research indicates that states that expanded Medicaid saw improvements in health insurance coverage rates and access to care, along with increased use of preventive services. Enrollment surged in expansion states, adding over 15.9 million new individuals to Medicaid programs since the ACA was introduced. For parents, coverage increased by 15.3 percentage points, while nonparents saw a 10.5 percentage point rise. In contrast, states that did not expand Medicaid have low coverage rates and worse health outcomes.

A Closer Look at Health Outcomes

The benefits of Medicaid expansion extend beyond enrollment statistics. Expansion states reported a significant reduction in avoidable healthcare usage. Parents in these areas experienced a 10.3% decrease in avoiding doctor visits because of financial issues. On the other hand, in non-expansion states, low-income individuals continued to delay necessary medical care, worsening existing health conditions.

Medicaid expansion has also increased the use of routine healthcare services. More individuals are likely to receive preventive care, including flu shots and mammograms. For instance, parents in expansion states reported a 2.8 percentage point rise in flu vaccinations, while nonparents had a 6.7 percentage point increase in mammogram screenings. These preventive measures contribute to better health outcomes, especially for chronic conditions.

Additionally, Medicaid expansion is linked to lower overall mortality rates. Research shows a 9.4% decline in mortality among non-elderly adults in expansion states. In contrast, high rates of preventable disease and death persist in non-expansion states.

Financial Impact on Patients

One immediate effect of Medicaid expansion is financial relief for individuals seeking medical care. The financial burdens associated with healthcare can discourage low-income patients from obtaining necessary treatment. Expansion states report decreased medical debt and fewer people avoiding medical care due to costs. These states show improved financial health, with lower Chapter 7 bankruptcy rates and a reduction in medical debt of about $6 billion.

Addressing Racial Disparities

The disparities in healthcare access for marginalized communities have been examined over the years. Medicaid expansion has helped reduce some of these disparities, particularly among Black and Latinx individuals who often face higher rates of being uninsured. Research suggests that Medicaid expansion has lessened racial disparities in health insurance coverage, with greater increases in coverage rates for minorities compared to white individuals. This reduction in disparities translates to improved access to essential healthcare services.

The American Rescue Plan of 2021 has further incentivized Medicaid expansion in non-expansion states. By expanding eligibility, millions of uninsured Black and Hispanic adults may gain access to healthcare, addressing long-standing inequities in health.

Challenges in Non-Expansion States

Despite the observed benefits in expansion states, political resistance is a major barrier to Medicaid expansion in many non-expansion states. Concerns about costs and opposition to the ACA have prevented some states from moving forward. For example, research shows that if Tennessee had expanded Medicaid, more than 16,300 additional residents would have gained health insurance by 2019.

Non-expansion states also encounter challenges in providing adequate healthcare. Many residents continue to face higher rates of chronic illnesses, delayed care, and avoidable hospitalizations, perpetuating health disparities.

The Role of Telehealth and Technological Innovations

As healthcare evolves, technological advancements are key to improving access to care. Telehealth has become a necessary service that complements Medicaid expansion, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. Telehealth services make it possible for patients to receive medical consultations without traveling long distances, which benefits those in rural areas or those who lack transportation.

The integration of telehealth into Medicaid programs enhances patient engagement and improves health outcomes. Individuals in expansion states can use telehealth services for routine check-ups, managing chronic conditions, and accessing mental health support, reducing barriers related to transportation and costs.

Optimizing Workflow with AI

Healthcare administrators and IT managers are looking to streamline operations. Implementing AI and automation in front-office services can significantly improve patient access and experience. For example, Simbo AI focuses on phone automation and answering services using AI technology. By automating patient inquiries, appointment scheduling, and follow-up calls, healthcare institutions can decrease patient wait times and increase service efficiency.

Using AI in workflows allows healthcare staff to focus on more complex patient needs while managing basic inquiries quickly. This improved efficiency can enhance patient satisfaction and retention while ensuring quality care in busy practices. Moreover, AI can aid organizations in collecting and analyzing patient interaction data, leading to a better understanding of patient needs and trends, which will ultimately enhance healthcare delivery.

Closing Remarks

Medicaid expansion has had a significant impact on access to healthcare in the U.S., effectively addressing coverage gaps, improving health outcomes, and supporting financial stability among low-income individuals. The differences between expansion and non-expansion states highlight the need for healthcare access reform. As healthcare continues to change, utilizing technology and innovative solutions will be essential for enhancing patient access and overall care quality across the country. Collaboration among healthcare administrators, policymakers, and technology providers is necessary to ensure that everyone, regardless of their state of residence, can access needed care.