Labor costs represent a significant expense for hospitals and healthcare providers across the United States, making up nearly 50% of total budgets. In recent years, there has been a notable increase in labor costs, largely due to contract staffing. This article discusses how these costs impact healthcare organizations and the shift toward contract staffing, which many hospitals have adopted to manage ongoing staffing shortages, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic.
A report by the American Hospital Association (AHA) shows that hospital expenses increased by approximately 17.5% from 2019 to 2022, significantly outpacing the Medicare reimbursement rise of only 7.5% during that same period. Labor costs rose by 20.8%, often driven by a greater reliance on contract staffing agencies to fulfill urgent patient care needs.
Since the pandemic began, hospitals have seen a dramatic 258% increase in contract labor expenses, indicating that healthcare facilities have turned to expensive staffing solutions to address long-standing labor shortages. This trend raises important questions about how long hospitals can sustain operations and provide quality care while managing these rising costs.
In light of staff shortages, hospitals often turn to contract labor to meet patient demands. However, this method can have significant effects on the financial health of a hospital. Labor costs in hospitals include more than just wages; they also cover training, supervision, and other expenses related to maintaining a consistent, high-quality workforce.
Workforce shortages have been reported nationally, with a notable increase in contract staffing during the COVID-19 pandemic. For example, NYC Health + Hospitals noted an 83% increase in temporary staffing from February 2020 to September 2022 while addressing severe staffing shortages. As hospitals struggle to recruit and retain full-time staff, many rely on contract workers, who often command higher pay than full-time employees.
The average salaries for travel nurses increased significantly during the pandemic, rising from about $1,896 per week in early 2020 to over $3,782 by December 2021. This dependence on contract personnel has led to rising operational costs and pressured budgets. In many cases, institutions like Bozeman Health in Montana reported declining revenues alongside increasing labor costs, resulting in cutbacks in staff and services.
By the end of 2022, more than half of U.S. hospitals reported financial losses. The ongoing rise in contract labor costs has negatively affected profit margins and created a challenging financial situation for many facilities. Hospitals often face tough decisions about how to allocate resources, and the high costs associated with contract staffing could lead to cuts in critical areas, which may ultimately impact patient care.
For instance, Bozeman Health’s monthly labor expenses reached $20 million, representing a 12% increase from the previous year. The facility’s contract labor costs rose dramatically, from under $100,000 before the pandemic to nearly $1.4 million monthly. The difficulties in turning contract workers into full-time employees complicate the recovery efforts, with many vacancies remaining unfilled.
As hospitals contend with increased labor costs, various strategies have emerged as possible solutions. Healthcare administrators recognize the need for a sustainable workforce, particularly given the intense competition for skilled professionals.
To reduce reliance on contract labor, many healthcare facilities are raising starting salaries and improving recruitment efforts to attract qualified candidates. A survey indicated that 98% of healthcare organizations employed one or more strategies for enhanced staff recruitment and retention.
By improving the working environment and addressing high turnover issues, hospitals aim to keep staff engaged and reduce attrition.
In today’s healthcare environment, technology addresses some urgent labor challenges faced by hospitals. Implementing AI and workflow automation can improve operational efficiency and lessen administrative burdens that consume valuable staff time.
Automation technologies help streamline various hospital tasks, such as scheduling and patient flow management. Automated scheduling systems allow hospitals to align staffing levels with patient needs more effectively, which reduces the need for costly contract workers. AI tools to forecast patient demand can also help administrators prepare for busy periods, ensuring proper staffing without resorting to expensive temporary solutions.
In billing and insurance—areas that contribute significantly to administrative costs—automation can bring substantial relief. Since administrative costs account for up to 31% of total healthcare spending, automating claims processing and prior authorization workflows can allow staff to focus more on patient care rather than paperwork. This increase in productivity can lead to higher job satisfaction and help retain key staff.
It is crucial for hospital management to invest in training staff to use these technologies, ensuring that both employees and organizations benefit from these advancements.
By adopting innovative staffing models like internal float pools and per diem staffing, hospitals can lessen their reliance on contract labor while maintaining the flexibility needed to handle changing demands. Float pools utilize trained staff as reserves across various departments. This not only draws from familiar team members who understand the organization but also avoids the higher costs associated with outside contract staff.
For instance, Memorial Healthcare System successfully moved away from contract staffing. By establishing internal staffing strategies, Memorial reduced its contract labor reliance by about 80%, resulting in savings of roughly $200 million.
It is important for hospital administrators to find a balance between controlling labor costs and delivering quality care. Unfortunately, managing rising costs has frequently led to negative outcomes, including longer patient wait times and reduced access to services. Additionally, nearly 90% of nurses reported that administrative burdens imposed by insurers have negatively impacted clinical outcomes, highlighting the need for change in healthcare management.
As labor costs rise and contract staffing becomes more common, healthcare administrators must adopt proactive management strategies to remain financially viable while ensuring quality patient care. By focusing on recruitment and retention, implementing technology and automation, utilizing innovative staffing models, and balancing labor costs with care quality, hospitals can work toward a more sustainable future.
With changing labor patterns, organizations such as Simbo AI will be crucial in helping healthcare providers navigate these adjustments. Utilizing technology effectively will allow hospitals to reshape their workforce strategies, improve efficiency, and enhance care delivery while managing rising costs. The future must incorporate innovative solutions that address current challenges and anticipate the needs of healthcare systems and communities.
Simbo is making doctors' and patients' lives better. Connect now to know more.
Schedule Demo Now© Since 2019, Simbo AI.
